Here is a comprehensive, in-depth article detailing the fascinating discovery of "flap-running" dinosaurs, exploring the science of trace fossils, and unraveling the complex history of avian flight.
The Raptor’s Leap: Fossil Tracks Suggest Feathered Dinosaurs GlidedIn the annals of paleontology, the story of flight has long been dominated by a binary question: could they fly, or couldn’t they? For over a century, scientists have scrutinized the hollow bones and asymmetrical feathers of ancient creatures, trying to determine the precise moment when ancestors of modern birds conquered the air. But a remarkable discovery in South Korea has upended this black-and-white narrative, offering a glimpse into a "grey zone" of evolution that is as dynamic as it is revolutionary.
Deep within the Cretaceous rock of the Jinju Formation, a set of tiny, unassuming footprints has told a story that bones alone never could. These tracks, left by a creature no larger than a sparrow, reveal a physical feat so impossible that it baffled the experts who found them. The stride lengths were simply too long—far too vast for a tiny animal to achieve with legs alone. The only explanation, verified by biomechanical analysis and aerodynamic modeling, is that this tiny dinosaur wasn't just running; it was cheating gravity. It was engaging in "flap-running," a behavior that bridges the gap between earthbound sprinting and powered flight, offering us the first behavioral evidence of how the raptor’s leap became the bird’s flight.
The Discovery: A Puzzle in the MudThe Jinju Formation in South Korea is a treasure trove for ichnologists—paleontologists who study trace fossils like footprints, burrows, and nests. Unlike body fossils, which preserve the physical structure of an animal after death, trace fossils capture a moment of life. They are behavior frozen in stone. In this diverse Cretaceous ecosystem, which dates back approximately 106 million years, the mudflats of ancient lakes preserved the movements of everything from massive sauropods to tiny invertebrates.
Among these fossilized pages of history, a team of researchers led by Dr. Kyung Soo Kim of Chinju National University of Education discovered a trackway that seemed to defy the laws of physics. The footprints were assigned the ichnotaxon name
Dromaeosauriformipes rarus. In the dry language of science, the name translates roughly to "rare footprints with the form of a dromaeosaur."Dromaeosaurs, popularly known as "raptors," are the family of carnivorous dinosaurs that includes the famous
Velociraptor and Deinonychus. They are characterized by their sharp, sickle-shaped claws on the second toe of each foot. Because dromaeosaurs held this "killing claw" off the ground to keep it sharp, their footprints are distinctively didactyl—they show only two toes (the third and fourth) making contact with the mud.The tracks found in the Jinju Formation were unmistakably dromaeosaurid. They possessed the classic two-toed impression. However, they were minuscule, left by an animal with feet only about 2.5 centimeters long. This would have been a creature roughly the size of a modern sparrow, likely a microraptorine—a subgroup of small, feathered raptors.
But the size wasn't the puzzle; the spacing was.
The Mathematics of Impossible Speed
To understand why these tracks caused such a stir, one must understand how paleontologists calculate dinosaur speed. In 1976, British zoologist R. McNeill Alexander developed a formula that allows scientists to estimate the speed of a dinosaur based on its stride length (the distance between two consecutive footprints of the same foot) and its hip height (estimated from the footprint size).
Generally, when an animal runs, its stride lengthens. A walking human might have a stride of less than a meter, while a sprinting Olympic athlete covers vast distances with each bound. However, there is a biomechanical limit. Legs can only push so hard and reach so far.
When Dr. Thomas Holtz Jr. of the University of Maryland and his colleagues applied these standard calculations to the
Dromaeosauriformipes rarus tracks, the results were nonsensical. The stride length was so enormous relative to the tiny size of the feet that the calculations suggested the dinosaur was moving at a velocity of 10.5 meters per second (roughly 23.5 miles per hour).While 23 mph might not sound like supersonic speed to a human driver, for an animal the size of a sparrow, it is ludicrous. Scaled up to the size of an ostrich or a cheetah, this relative speed would shatter biological limits. If a sparrow-sized animal were truly running that fast using only leg power, its muscles would need to generate force far beyond what biological tissues can sustain. It would be the equivalent of a human running at highway speeds.
The researchers were left with a distinct set of possibilities:
- The "Stilts" Theory: The dinosaur had grotesquely long legs, completely unlike any known dromaeosaur.
- The Missing Tracks: The animal was hopping, and the preservation conditions failed to record intermediate landing spots.
- The Gravity Cheat: The animal was generating lift.
The first two theories were quickly discarded based on anatomical knowledge of microraptorines and the clear, continuous nature of the sediment layers. That left the third, and most thrilling, possibility. The dinosaur was not just running; it was flapping.
Flap-Running: The Biomechanics of Lift
The concept of "flap-running" fundamentally changes how we visualize the movement of early feathered dinosaurs. This behavior is not flight in the sense of a bird taking off from a branch and soaring into the sky. Instead, it is a hybrid form of locomotion.
Imagine an aircraft accelerating down a runway. Before it lifts off completely, there is a moment where the wings are generating significant lift, effectively reducing the weight of the plane on the wheels. The plane is still touching the ground, but it is "light."
The researchers propose that the maker of the
Dromaeosauriformipes rarus tracks was doing exactly this. As it sprinted across the Cretaceous mudflat, likely fleeing a predator or chasing prey, it began to flap its feathered forelimbs.Dromaeosaurs like
Microraptor possessed extensive feathering on their arms (and often legs) that formed broad, bird-like wings. By flapping these wings while running, the dinosaur created aerodynamic lift. This lift didn't necessarily carry it into the clouds, but it counteracted gravity enough to pull its body upward.This aerodynamic assistance allowed the animal to:
- Increase Hang Time: With each step, the lift kept the dinosaur airborne for a fraction of a second longer than gravity would normally allow.
- Lengthen Stride: longer airtime means the animal travels further forward before its foot must strike the ground again.
- Maintain Speed: By reducing the friction and impact with the ground, the animal could move faster and more efficiently.
This behavior turns the tracks from a simple record of a run into a "smoking gun" for the evolution of flight. It suggests that the transition from ground-dwelling theropods to sky-conquering avians involved a phase of "power-assisted running."
The Actor: Meet the Microraptorines
To fully appreciate this behavior, we must look at the actor behind the footprints. While we cannot identify the exact species from tracks alone, the morphology points directly to the microraptorines.
The most famous of this group is
Microraptor gui, discovered in the Liaoning province of China. Living roughly 120 million years ago, Microraptor is one of the most bizarre and revealing dinosaurs ever found. Unlike modern birds, which have a single pair of wings, Microraptor was a four-winged glider. It had long, asymmetric flight feathers not just on its arms, but also on its hind legs.For years, paleontologists debated how
Microraptor moved. Did it sprawl its legs to form a biplane wing? Did it tuck its legs under? Most importantly, was it a tree-dweller (arboreal) or a ground-dweller (cursorial)?The "Trees-Down" hypothesis suggested that
Microraptor climbed trees and glided down like a flying squirrel. Its anatomy seemed ill-suited for running on the ground; long feathers on the legs would presumably trip it up or get damaged.However, the tracks in South Korea challenge the exclusivity of the "Trees-Down" model. They show a microraptorine moving at high speed
on the ground. This implies that despite their cumbersome leg feathers, these animals were capable terrestrial runners. It also suggests that their wings were not just passive gliding structures used for descent but active aerodynamic tools used for acceleration on the flat.This aligns with the "Ground-Up" hypothesis, or more specifically, the "Wing-Assisted Incline Running" (WAIR) theory. WAIR is observed in modern birds like Chukar partridges. When these birds are chicks and cannot yet fly, they use their developing wings to flap furiously while running up steep inclines (like tree trunks or cliffs). The flapping pushes them
into the surface, giving their feet better traction.The
Dromaeosauriformipes tracks suggest a variation of this: Wing-Assisted Running on the flat. The flapping wasn't for traction; it was for speed and stride elongation. It paints a picture of a versatile predator that was comfortable in the trees but lethal on the ground—a creature that used the air as a tool long before it fully conquered it.The Spectrum of Flight Evolution
The significance of the "Raptor's Leap" lies in how it blurs the lines of classification. We humans love categories. A bat flies; a mouse walks. A penguin swims; an eagle soars. But evolution is rarely so tidy. It is a messy, gradual process of tinkering.
The discovery of flap-running tracks confirms that flight was not a singular invention that appeared overnight. It was a spectrum of locomotor behaviors.
- Passive Parachuting: Simple slowing of a fall.
- Gliding: Controlled descent from height (likely practiced by many early microraptorines).
- Flap-Running: Using wings to assist ground movement (evidenced by these tracks).
- Weak Powered Flight: Burst flights for escape, lacking the stamina for migration (likely early birds like
The tiny dinosaur in South Korea was operating in the middle of this spectrum. It had the hardware for flight (feathers, wings) but was using them to enhance its terrestrial hardware (legs, claws).
This "mosaic evolution" explains why we see so many "experimental" dinosaur forms in the Cretaceous. There were dinosaurs with bat-like membrane wings (
Yi qi), dinosaurs with four feathered wings (Microraptor), and dinosaurs with stiff tails and half-wings (Caudipteryx). Nature was throwing aerodynamic spaghetti at the wall to see what stuck. The lineage that led to modern birds was simply the one that mastered the transition from flap-running and gliding to sustained, powered flight.Trace Fossils: The Unsung Heroes
This discovery also highlights the critical importance of trace fossils. Body fossils—bones and teeth—tell us
what an animal looked like. They give us the chassis of the car. Trace fossils tell us how the animal drove the car.Finding the tracks of a sparrow-sized dinosaur is a geological miracle. Footprints in mud usually wash away with the next rain or tide. For tracks to be preserved, the sediment must be the right consistency—sticky enough to hold the shape, but not so wet that it slumps. It then needs to be buried gently and rapidly by a new layer of sediment to protect it from the elements.
The Jinju Formation is unique because of its fine-grained lacustrine (lake) deposits. The mud was fine enough to capture the exquisite detail of tiny toe pads and claw marks. These tracks are so delicate that they were likely made on the shore of a drying lake, baked by the Cretaceous sun just enough to harden before being buried.
Dr. Kim, Dr. Lockley, and their colleagues had to act as forensic detectives. They didn't just measure distance; they analyzed the depth of the prints. In a normal run, the force exerted on the ground is proportional to speed. A sprinting animal hits the ground hard. But these tracks were relatively shallow for the speeds implied by the stride length. This shallowness was the final clue: the animal wasn't hitting the ground with its full weight. It was being lifted.
A Window into the Cretaceous World
Let us reconstruct the scene based on this study.
It is late morning in the Early Cretaceous of the Korean Peninsula. The landscape is dotted with active volcanoes in the distance, but here, by the lakeshore, it is quiet. The air is humid and thick with insects.
A small microraptorine emerges from the fern scrub. It is a striking animal, perhaps iridescent black like a crow (as suggested by melanosome studies of
Microraptor fossils), with feathers streamlining its body and a long, stiff tail acting as a rudder. It is hungry.Suddenly, a predator appears—perhaps a larger theropod, or maybe a sudden noise startles it. The microraptorine bolts. It starts with a run, its two-toed feet kicking up small spurts of mud. As it accelerates, it instinctively unfurls its forelimbs. The long flight feathers catch the air. It begins to flap.
Whoosh. Whoosh.With each downstroke, it feels a tug upward. Its feet spend less time on the mud and more time in the air. It bounds forward in impossibly long leaps—one meter, two meters. To an observer, it would look like a stone skipping across water, half-running, half-hovering.
It reaches the safety of a tree trunk and uses its momentum to run vertically up the bark (WAIR), its claws gripping the wood, wings still beating to pin it against the tree. High in the branches, it looks down. On the mudflat below, it has left a message that will wait 100 million years to be read: a set of tracks that defy gravity.
Conclusion: The blurry Line Between Earth and Sky
The study of the
Dromaeosauriformipes rarus* tracks is a triumph of modern paleontology. It combines traditional fieldwork with biomechanical modeling to extract dynamic behavior from static stone. It reminds us that the distinction between "dinosaur" and "bird" is largely semantic.In the Late Cretaceous, the line between running and flying was not a wall, but a ramp. Dinosaurs didn't just look at the sky and wish to fly; they ran toward it, flapped at it, and eventually, leaped into it. The tiny tracks in South Korea are the enduring footprints of that leap, proving that long before the first eagle soared, the raptors were already testing the limits of the air. They were the pioneers of the vertical world, and their legacy is the sky full of birds we see today.
Reference:
- https://www.latimes.com/science/sciencenow/la-sci-sn-microraptor-dinosaur-flight-wind-tunnel-20130918-story.html
- https://croucher.org.hk/en/news/tracing-the-footsteps-of-flight
- https://www.popsci.com/science/field-museum-bird-dinosaur/
- https://cmns.umd.edu/news-events/news/thomas-holtz-helps-solve-mystery-microraptorine-footprints
- https://www.sci.news/paleontology/dromaeosauriformipes-rarus-13365.html
- https://www.zmescience.com/feature-post/natural-sciences/geology-and-paleontology/dinosaurs/velociraptor/
- https://www.discovermagazine.com/this-100-million-year-old-microraptor-flapped-its-arms-while-running-46854
- https://www.independent.co.uk/news/science/dinosaur-fossil-tracks-raptor-wings-b2633288.html
- https://medium.com/prehistoric-tales/running-to-takeoff-south-korean-footprints-unveil-dinosaurs-early-flight-experiments-48a9a894605b
- https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2413810121
- https://science.howstuffworks.com/environmental/earth/geology/stone-dinosaur-track.htm
- http://novataxa.blogspot.com/2024/10/dromaeosauriformipes.html
- https://www.sciencenews.org/article/dinosaur-microraptor-hawk-fossil-foot