Archaeovocology: Language Complexity in Wild Orangutan Multi-Layered Calls

The haunting calls of wild orangutans echoing through the dense rainforests of Indonesia are offering profound new insights into the very origins of human language. For years, it was believed that certain complex features of language, particularly recursion—the ability to embed linguistic structures within one another like Russian nesting dolls—were uniquely human. However, groundbreaking research is revealing that these gentle, arboreal apes possess a vocal sophistication that challenges this long-held assumption, suggesting the roots of complex communication run much deeper in our shared evolutionary past.

At the heart of this research is the discovery that wild Sumatran orangutans ( Pongo abelii) structure their alarm calls in a remarkably complex, multi-layered fashion. Scientists, notably from the University of Warwick, have found that these calls exhibit what is known as third-order recursion. This means that individual sounds are combined into small sequences, these sequences are then grouped into longer, more complex bouts, and finally, these bouts are arranged into extended, rhythmic series. Each layer is nested within the next, creating a hierarchical and rhythmic structure previously thought to be a hallmark of human language alone.

To illustrate recursion, consider the children's rhyme, "This is the house that Jack built." The phrase can be extended by embedding more phrases: "This is the dog that chased the cat that killed the rat that ate the cheese." Each segment builds upon the previous one, forming a layered and connected structure. Researchers have found analogous patterns in the rhythmic alarm calls of female Sumatran orangutans.

These intricate vocal patterns are not random; orangutans dynamically adjust the rhythm and structure of their calls based on the perceived threat. When faced with an immediate and credible danger, like a tiger, their calls become faster, more urgent, and more rhythmically regular. Conversely, if the threat is less clear or ambiguous, such as a brightly colored cloth that researchers used to simulate a non-threatening but novel stimulus, the calls are slower and less regular. This adaptability demonstrates that orangutans are not simply making noise but are using structured vocalizations to convey specific and meaningful information about their environment and the nature of potential dangers.

This discovery is significant because it pushes back the potential timeline for the evolution of recursive structures in communication. It suggests that the cognitive foundations for such complex communication may have already been present in our common ancestors with great apes millions of years ago. The study of these orangutan calls, a field one might term 'archaeovocology', provides a window into how the fundamental building blocks of language might have emerged and evolved.

Research into the vocalizations of Bornean orangutans (Pongo pygmaeus wurmbii) has also contributed to this understanding. Studies on the "long call" produced by flanged (mature) male Bornean orangutans revealed a two-level rhythmic hierarchy, indicating a recursive structure in their calls as well. These long calls, which can travel over a kilometer, primarily function as spacing mechanisms between males and as a mating strategy to attract females. The calls begin with soft grumbles, intensify into bark-like pulses or roars, and end with sighs, with cheek pads and laryngeal air sacs enhancing their projection. The finding of second-order recursion in male Bornean orangutans, and the even more complex third-order recursion in female Sumatran orangutans' alarm calls, highlights the sophisticated vocal abilities across different orangutan populations and call types.

The concept of archaeovocology allows us to explore how these ancient vocal capacities could have laid the groundwork for human language. It's not just about the presence of recursion, but also about other linguistic elements. For instance, research has shown that orangutans possess a surprisingly varied vocal repertoire that can differ based on geography, indicating potential cultural variations in their communication. They are also capable of vocal learning and producing novel calls, abilities once thought to be limited or absent in great apes. An orangutan named Rocky, for example, learned to mimic human-produced sounds ("wookies") that were not part of the typical orangutan vocal repertoire, demonstrating fine control over his vocal folds. Furthermore, the "kiss squeak," a voiceless consonant-like call produced through actions of the lips, tongue, and jaw, is used by orangutans in different combinations to convey varied meanings, much like humans use consonants. The arboreal lifestyle of orangutans, requiring sophisticated use of their mouths as a 'fifth hand' for manipulating food and tools, may have contributed to their advanced oral neuro-motor control, a potential preadaptation for the emergence of consonants.

These findings challenge the traditional view that human language evolved in a sudden leap, separate from the communicative abilities of other primates. Instead, they support a model of gradual evolutionary selection and refinement, where the "seeds of language structure" began to grow millions of years ago. While human language is undoubtedly unique in its overall complexity and symbolic representation, the discovery of multi-layered, recursive calls in orangutans suggests that some of its core cognitive and structural components have deep evolutionary roots.

It is important to note that while orangutans exhibit these complex vocal structures, their "language" is still fundamentally different from human language. They have a limited set of foundational units compared to the vast lexicon of human languages. However, the way they organize these units into layered, rhythmic, and context-dependent calls demonstrates a level of communicative complexity that was previously underestimated.

The implications of this research extend beyond understanding language evolution. They underscore the incredible cognitive abilities of orangutans and highlight the urgent need for their conservation. These intelligent great apes, with whom we share approximately 97% of our DNA, are critically endangered due to habitat loss and other human-induced threats. By studying their complex communication, we not only gain invaluable insights into our own evolutionary journey but also a deeper appreciation for these remarkable creatures and the importance of protecting their forest homes.

The field of archaeovocology, by delving into the ancient echoes within primate calls, continues to unravel the intricate tapestry of language evolution. The rhythmic and multi-layered vocalizations of wild orangutans serve as a living link to our distant past, reminding us that meaningful communication can take many forms and that the roots of our own sophisticated language may lie not just in what is said, but in how it is expressed and structured. As we continue to listen to and learn from our primate cousins, we may uncover even more about the fascinating journey of how language came to be.

Reference: