Astrophysics: Cosmic Misfits: Giant Planets Around Tiny Stars Challenge Formation Theories

In the vast and ever-expanding theater of the cosmos, astronomers are accustomed to seeing a certain order. Like finds like; massive stars are often accompanied by massive planets, a logical consequence of the raw materials available for creation. However, the universe, in its infinite variety, occasionally throws a wrench in our neat and tidy models. Recent discoveries have unveiled a cast of "cosmic misfits"—enormous gas giants circling diminutive red dwarf stars, a phenomenon that challenges the very foundations of our understanding of how planets are born.

The Conventional Recipe for Planet Formation

For decades, two leading theories have dominated the discussion on planetary genesis: core accretion and gravitational instability.

The most widely accepted of these is the core accretion model. This "bottom-up" approach posits that planets form from the gradual accumulation of solid materials within a protoplanetary disk—a vast, spinning disk of gas and dust surrounding a young star. Tiny dust grains stick together, growing into pebbles, then planetesimals, and eventually, the rocky cores of planets. If a core becomes massive enough—typically around 10 times the mass of Earth—its gravity becomes powerful enough to rapidly pull in vast amounts of gas from the surrounding disk, birthing a gas giant like Jupiter. This model elegantly explains the formation of many planets in our own solar system and beyond.

The alternative, the gravitational instability model, is a "top-down" approach. It suggests that in a particularly massive and cool protoplanetary disk, dense regions can collapse under their own gravity, directly forming a giant planet in a much shorter timescale. This process is thought to be more efficient in the outer, colder regions of a disk and is considered a possible explanation for the formation of massive gas giants and brown dwarfs.

A fundamental assumption underpinning these theories is that the size of the star dictates the size of its planetary companions. Massive stars possess massive protoplanetary disks with a wealth of material for building large planets. Conversely, low-mass stars, like the ubiquitous red dwarfs, are expected to have proportionately smaller and less massive disks, making the formation of giant planets around them a rare, if not impossible, event.

A Parade of Impossible Worlds

Recent discoveries, however, have presented astronomers with a gallery of celestial objects that seemingly defy these established rules.

TOI-5205b: The "Forbidden" Planet

One of the most striking examples is TOI-5205b, a Jupiter-sized gas giant orbiting a red dwarf star, TOI-5205, that is only about four times the size of Jupiter itself. Discovered using data from NASA's Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite (TESS), this "forbidden" planet, located about 285 light-years from Earth, has left astronomers puzzled. Shubham Kanodia of the Carnegie Earth & Planets Lab aptly described the system's odd proportions: while Jupiter's orbit around the Sun is akin to a pea circling a grapefruit, TOI-5205b is more like a pea orbiting a lemon.

The existence of TOI-5205b directly challenges the core accretion model. The protoplanetary disk of a star as small as TOI-5205 should not have contained enough rocky material to form the massive core needed to birth a gas giant. The planet is so large relative to its star that when it transits, or passes in front of it, it blocks a staggering seven percent of the star's light. This significant dimming makes TOI-5205b an excellent candidate for follow-up observations by the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) to study its atmosphere and potentially unlock the secrets of its formation.

LHS 3154 b: A Heavyweight in a Lightweight Division

Another perplexing discovery is LHS 3154 b, a Neptune-like planet with a mass about 13 times that of Earth, orbiting a tiny red dwarf star (LHS 3154) that is only about one-ninth the mass of our sun. Located roughly 50 light-years away, this planet is so massive relative to its star that its formation is difficult to explain with current models. Scientists who discovered it using the Habitable Zone Planet Finder noted that computer simulations indicate the protoplanetary disk would have needed at least 10 times more material than is generally assumed for such a low-mass star.

The discovery of LHS 3154 b, announced in late 2023, has added to the growing body of evidence that our understanding of planet formation is incomplete. Co-author Suvrath Mahadevan remarked, "This discovery really drives home the point of just how little we know about the universe...We wouldn't expect a planet this heavy around such a low-mass star to exist".

TOI-6894b: The Newest Anomaly

More recently, in June 2025, an international team of astronomers announced the discovery of TOI-6894b, a Saturn-sized gas giant orbiting the smallest known star to host such a large companion. The host star, TOI-6894, is a red dwarf with a mere 20% of the sun's mass, making it a typical resident of our galaxy. The planet itself has a radius slightly larger than Saturn but only about half its mass, suggesting it has a very low density.

The existence of TOI-6894b is incredibly difficult to reconcile with existing models of planet formation. The star is the lowest-mass star ever found with a giant planet, and according to current theories, its protoplanetary disk would have lacked the necessary material to form such a massive world. This discovery, stemming from a large-scale analysis of TESS data, further underscores the need for a re-evaluation of our planetary formation theories.

Rewriting the Cosmic Rulebook

These cosmic misfits are forcing a paradigm shift in astrophysics. The discovery of giant planets around small stars suggests that our models may be too simplistic or that alternative formation mechanisms are at play. Several possibilities are being explored:

Pebble Accretion: A variation of the core accretion model, pebble accretion, suggests that instead of accumulating large planetesimals, planetary cores can grow much more rapidly by sweeping up vast numbers of smaller, pebble-sized objects. This could potentially accelerate core growth enough to form giant planets around smaller stars before their protoplanetary disks dissipate.
Gravitational Instability Revisited: While gravitational instability is generally thought to occur in massive disks, perhaps certain conditions could allow it to operate in smaller disks than previously believed.
Disk Replenishment: It's possible that protoplanetary disks are not isolated systems. They might be able to replenish their material by pulling in more dust and gas from the larger molecular cloud that surrounds them.

The Promise of Future Observations

The James Webb Space Telescope is poised to play a crucial role in solving these cosmic puzzles. Its powerful instruments can analyze the starlight that passes through the atmospheres of these exoplanets, revealing their chemical composition. The presence or absence of certain elements and molecules can provide vital clues about how and where a planet formed. For example, the atmospheric composition of a planet formed through gravitational instability is expected to be similar to its host star, while a planet formed via core accretion should have a higher metal content.

The surprisingly cool atmosphere of TOI-6894b, with temperatures low enough that ammonia might be detectable, offers a particularly exciting opportunity for JWST to conduct the first-ever detection of ammonia in an exoplanet's atmosphere.

In conclusion, the discovery of giant planets orbiting tiny stars is a testament to the fact that the universe is far more complex and surprising than we can imagine. These "cosmic misfits" are not just astronomical curiosities; they are signposts pointing toward a deeper and more complete understanding of the processes that create the incredible diversity of worlds beyond our solar system. As we continue to explore the cosmos with increasingly powerful tools, we can be sure that more of these "impossible" worlds await, ready to challenge our assumptions and expand our cosmic horizons.

The Conventional Recipe for Planet Formation

A Parade of Impossible Worlds

Rewriting the Cosmic Rulebook

The Promise of Future Observations

Reference: